Last week while having a passionate food discussion, I told my cohorts that one of the reasons I don’t eat animal products is because I disagree with the way animals are raised in the United States. The answer to that charge was that you can go to Whole Foods and buy “Organic” “Free Range” chicken. We can “trust” Whole Foods wouldn’t sell us Free Range chicken that isn’t REALLY Free Range. Unfortunately, Whole Foods has no choice, because the United States government allows any CAFO (Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation) to use the “Free Range” Label with only the most meager additions to their compounds.
Eating organic chicken everyday is still extremely bad for your health and has been linked to cancer, heart disease, obesity, and many other horrible illnesses. All organic means is that the Chicken ate “Organic” corn. To make matters worse, neither label means that the animals were treated in an ethical manor.
free range is not free range
To quote the USDA website:
FREE RANGE or FREE ROAMING:
Producers must demonstrate to the Agency that the poultry has been allowed access to the outside.
And yet more disturbing quotes:
FSIS approves “free range” raising claims in the labeling of poultry products if the producer demonstrate that the birds were allowed continuous, free access to the outside for over 51 percent of their lives.
Some producers may support a “free range” claim if the source birds were allowed access to a yard, regardless of whether the birds use the yard.
What this means is that “Free Range” chickens can be kept in cells the size of their bodies for half their lives. Then the other half of their lives are spent crammed into huge warehouses with tens of thousands of5 other birds. The entire warehouse full of birds can be labeled free range as long as there is a part of the building that is open to the air.
Most chickens have been fattened so quickly that their undeveloped legs barely allow them to move, let alone walk around on in a bare “yard”. They spend their entire lives next to the feeding trough. A chicken’s natural environment is a forested shady place safe from the sun, wind, and predators. Chickens will actually prefer the warehouse to a sun-exposed, muddy, and windy patch of earth.
Michael Pollen wrote,”the chickens are given outside access at 5 weeks, then killed at 7 weeks. He never saw a chicken go outside during his visit. ” So the next time your at Whole Foods looking at Rosie the “Free Range Chicken”, remind yourself of the “Free Range” lie, and buy food that you know was raised without animal cruelty. If your still not convinced Rosie’s life wasn’t rosie, check out the Whole Foods blog. Turkey’s crammed wall to wall. Make sure you read the comments because Whole Foods tries to defend it’s reliance on concentrated animal farming methods while carefully refusing to answer the questions around how much space and time it’s birds spend outside.
Turkey’s maybe social in small groups, but when you jam thousands of equally social chickens into warehouses they become violent and start killing each other. The industry answer to birds mutilating each other is to mutilate the baby birds first by cutting off their beaks and claws.
Related:
Did you enjoy: The Free Range Lie? Then subscribe to The Casual Vegan by Email or you should follow me on twitter here.
The Next Post: Mango Jicama Salad
The Previous Post: Preventing Heart Disease
Comments About The Free Range Lie
// 4 comments so far.
eyerouge // May 04th 2009
Black slaves were also raoming around “free range”-style, at least some did to some extent, just like birds do in the animal industry complex. Then again, it never made them less slaves, less exploited… not less of a mean to their masters end.
sarahfae // May 04th 2009
Thanks for posting this! I’ve discussed this topic many times before, and my husband (who works at our local natural foods store) actually was the first to tell me the difference between “free range” and “cage free” chicken. This is a good reminder.
Greg // May 06th 2009
Thanks for your comments. While I’m not a lawyer, as far as I can tell, “cage free” has no legal definition. If enough people become aware of the hollow standards set by the USDA, then consumers will become more demanding in calling for stronger standards. For a long time I too shut my eyes to animal cruelty and many people still do. However, being a plant-based eater makes it easier to see that stronger labeling on food is an extremely important cause. It’s time to write more posts about food labels…
Tweek // October 23rd 2011
@ eyerouge. Okay, it is three years later. You probably don’t even post here anymore, but, really? You’re comparing the AIC to the autrocity of human enslavement? Please, do some research. The one in no way compares to the other. What happens within the AIC may be unethical. Human enslavement is immoral.
You can follow any responses to this entry via its RSS comments feed. You may also leave a trackback by clicking this link.